Oh boy, I might get a lot of hate for this one.
For those of you that don't know (those probably born when he cooled off; Jesus I feel old), Nelly was a huge thing in the early 2000s on this side of Eminem. Seriously, pretty much everyone knew who he was and listened to the man's music, whether it was your parents, your school teacher, your friends, or some middle aged dude trying to look hip and "in". I remember everyone had this album back in the day, myself included. He was to rap music at the time like Lionel Messi is to soccer right now, pretty much the most well known at the time. Hell, the dude beefed with KRS-One, a beef that, unfortunately to say, was mostly pointless, since most of Nelly's fanbase probably didn't know who KRS-one is.
Before 2000, Nelly, or Cornell Haynes, Jr, was pretty much unheard of at the time, and was mostly a faceless underground rapper from St. Louis, whose hip hop scene wasn't well known compared to grimy New York, or sunny California. Familial issues were the reason why he ended up there in the first place, and took up the pen and pad in 1993, over baseball (seriously). Throughout the 1990s he tried making various failed attempts at the mainstream via his weed carriers the St. Lunatics. After winning an apple bobbing contest, Nelly was chosen as the rapper to send random mixtapes to various recording companies, in hopes he'd get picked up.
Universal Records came calling.
Even with the new deal, it looked to be a disaster; Nelly was seen as a douche by his co-workers and even hated on his music; whether this was purely personal is not clear. Universal tried marketing him as the new kid who happened to be different, in a time where Puff Daddy and Master P were watering down the industry. Even then, it looked to be hopeless... then he blew up, because his music was so damn catchy. Given the quality of albums 1998-2000, it's not too surprising either.
It's been nearly two decades, and now Nelly just makes himself look like an idiot with the autotune and trap laced "The Fix" alongside Jeremih. Does this even hold up? Let's find out.
1. INTRO (FEAT. CEDRIC THE ENTERTAINER) - Wow, that was pointless.
2. ST. LOUIE - To start off proceedings, we begin with an instrumental that in all honestly, knocks. Jason "Jay E" Epperson's beat, which mostly consists of a disco-derived bassline as well as some use of a piano, is incredibly catchy, alongside Nelly's hook of St. Louis being home to gun violence, cocaine, blue collar workers and swingers. Nelly's lyrics, however, aren't nearly so; it's pretty apparent that he's simplistic at best. His flow isn't too bad, so honestly this song was all right, though I really couldn't tell if this was a street anthem or a club song, it seems to do both, but at the same time, neither.
3. GREED, HATE, ENVY - It looks like we're going into that territory already, eh? In an obvious attempt at extensive airplay, Nelly adopts a radio-friendly flow, rapping about what Eazy-E's merry weed carriers rapped about in 1995, jealousy, just packaged as "Greed, Hate & Envy". Nelly's pitch-high screeching is irritating as hell, so you can't even listen to the man's word without your eardrum being irritated; this song itself seems pretty ironic given Nelly's negative reputation with his labelmates, so maybe this was some ranting session. City Spud's beat is a Neptunes imitation, even jacking elements of Noreaga's "Superthug", which sampled elements of Blondie's "Heart of Glass". Even Noreaga himself is name-dropped here. Overall, this song was a mess. If this is indicative of the album, we have an issue here.
4. COUNTRY GRAMMAR (HOT SHIT) - You probably all know this one. The first single, this was quite a big song back then, and I bet the album sold based on this (and even more on another single we'll get to) song. For what it's worth, this song is actually catchy. Jay E's beat is very simplistic, if not monotonous, but doesn't suck. Haynes sounds at home over this beat though, as he rides this through with his Missouri twang-derived flow and shit-talking lyrics. Honestly, for a pop rap song, this could've been a lot worse. At least, Nelly actually raps, not the delirious bullshit that passes as "rapping" these days. Not bad.
5. STEAL THE SHOW (FEAT. THE ST. LUNATICS) - And pretty quickly we go back to music that can be at best described as mediocre. In the inevitable weed carrier track, the St. Lunatics pretty much rap about fame, fortune, and getting head, probably via Nelly. City Spud and Murphy Lee verses are purely about getting head, so honestly I'm surprised Too $hort didn't appear on this track, but then again he was stuck as a crony at Jive. Epperson's beat is plodding and sounds like a bunch of phone sounds turned into a pulsating beat which is meh. Pretty forgettable.
6. INTERLUDE (CEDRIC THE ENTERTAINER) - Refer to track one
7. RIDE WIT ME (FEAT. CITY SPUD) - Believe me, you definitely know this one. Seriously, everyone I knew was playing this track. It was sort of like the Black Plague; infectious, and you couldn't escape it. Seriously, this album pretty much succeeded on this track. Even before its release as a single in 2001, this was everywhere. The song itself; Epperson's beat is pretty decent. Epperson uses elements of DeBarge's "I Like It" to great effect, so the beat gives off a really nice night time, partying champagne vibe. Nelly's bars are probably the best in his career, mixing lyrics of just getting wasted at the club with pretty introspective personal lyrics that are vague enough to be relate-able. City Spud is pretty much ass at the end of the song, but his verse doesn't detract from the rest of the song, and catchy hook. What I'm saying is that this song is actually pretty good.
8. E.I. - Another song which pretty much helped this LP sell. In an album to promiscuity at parties, Epperson creates another beat that is pretty simplistic with electric cues, and Nelly pretty much gets to work here. I'll be honest, I don't enjoy this as much as I did circa 2001, though recalling people sing this hook (which is mangled Spanish) innocently is pretty amusing. Still, this isn't completely horrible.
9. THICKY THICK GIRL (FEAT. MURPHY LEE & ALI) - Okay, that bass sounds very familiar. It almost sounds like if our man behind the boards City Spud (I guess Jay E was too busy playing Mortal Kombat or something) sampled RBL Posse's "Listen To My Creep", which actually in turn sampled A Tribe Called Quest's "Jazz (We've Got)"; there is no sample credited, so there's a very distinct possibility that City Spud was being very naughty, and no one noticed. Or it could be my millennial ears trying to make some connection to two or three songs which are otherwise completely different. Notice how I didn't write about the song itself.
10. FOR MY (FEAT. LIL WAYNE) - Yes, that Lil Wayne. This was before Lil Wayne really blew up and didn't completely suck, but nonetheless his verse is pretty much garbage, as you could've predicted. Nelly isn't much better, and the hook here is god-awful. Seriously, this is just a fail, even by 2000 standards this was bad. No wonder this has been pretty much spending its time in the depths of hell.
11. UTHA SIDE - I actually had no idea what the hell Nelly was rapping about here. Perhaps this track was about Nelly picking up upper class white girls from the suburbs, while all participants simultaneously hold the listener at gun point and forcibly into Nelly's lowrider, with Nelly lecturing them about the serious issues of American inner cities, where said low-rider just so happened to be car-jacked, but the car jackers decided to buy Budweisers for everyone involved, because this is a pop rap song. Epperson's beat? Meh.
12. THO DEM WRAPPAS - Oh wow, this was terrible. It seems Nelly attempts to conjure up some of that gangsta shit the audience was clamoring for, over a beat that sounds like a mix between generic low-rated horror movie samples and the same electric-derived samples we've been derived from. Nelly's lyrics are pretty much unfocused, so there's no sense of unity on this song.
13. WRAP SUMDEN (FEAT. ST. LUNATICS) - The inevitable weed anthem. Well, at least Nelly and the St. Lunatics actually sound like they're high. But unfortunately this song is filled too much with the usual weed cliches that only makes you want to play Luniz and Cypress Hill instead, who were much better with this shit. I'll admit, it's amusing to hear all our participants yell out "rap song", as if this was the only rap album the listeners have heard.
14. BATTER UP (FEAT. MURPHY LEE & ALI) - The fourth, and last single, of the album. Actually, the beat, this time by Steve "Blast" Wills, is pretty fucking catchy, with the use of electric notes and bass being pretty damn effective. The lyrics on here, of course, suck, but this song enters that area where it's so corny, it's actually not that bad, because you can't take it so seriously. Nelly himself is pretty amusing with his line of "I'm eating Wheaties now!". Though I'm still wondering why they won't cook said fish in the kitchen, or burn said beans. Believe me, burned beans are bad news.
15. NEVER LET 'EM C U SWEAT (FEAT. THE TEAMSTERS) - City Spud pretty much recycles the beat to track 13, which at least wasn't awful. The Teamsters are pretty much weed carriers you won't hear about ever again; the whole song is pretty much supposed to be a generic "tough street life, do your best" track, like it hadn't been done one billion times before.
16. LUVEN ME - The last song of the album. City Spud provides the last beat of the album, which sounds more like a G-funk beat; it pretty much uses One Way's "Don't Ever Stop Loving Me", as Warren G used in 1994, though Warren G's beat was better, but this sounds like the most distinct beat on the LP. Nelly's lyrics dedicated to his hard working mother, his (I presume) ex girlfriend whom we aren't told by name, and his merry weed carriers, are heartfelt, though very simple. Not a bad way to end proceedings.
17. OUTRO (FEAT. CEDRIC THE ENTERTAINER) - And with that, we're done with Country Grammar.
FINAL WORD - Let's be honest, Country Grammar was never a good album to begin with, and Nelly pretty much blew up only because he happened to strike gold twice. At the best, Nelly is a competent enough rapper whose lyricism is bordering on mediocrity, but even then manages to make lightning strike. At worst, he comes off as a hack, and it's pretty easy to see why his labelmates didn't like this album too much before it was released. Nelly came in an era of one hit wonders, watered down releases, failed comebacks, and what was seen as the decline of hip hop. A lot of the album features boring cliches and monotonous lyrics, honestly we've all heard better. It's just not a good album. Even if some of the forgettable songs on here are better than the rest of the man's catalog, and hip hop in 2016.
BUY OR BURN? - You'll definitely want to burn this
one. As a whole it pretty much falls apart, which is why we have the internet.
BEST TRACKS - "Ride Wit Me", "Country Grammar (Hot Shit)", "St. Louie", "Batter Up", "Luven Me"